When choosing a path to becoming a physician, aspiring medical students in the U.S. often grapple with the decision between obtaining a Doctor of Osteopathic Medicine (DO) or a Doctor of Medicine (MD) degree. While MDs represent the more traditional route of medical education in allopathic medicine, DOs are trained in osteopathic medicine, which incorporates a holistic approach to patient care. Understanding the difference between MD and DO degrees, and why someone might choose a DO, requires exploring the philosophies, training, and opportunities that each pathway offers.
Check out this popular article discussing D.O. doctors versus M.D. doctors
Another popular article can be found here and focuses on Can a DO Become an MD?
Allopathic and Osteopathic Medicine: What’s the Difference?
MD stands for Doctor of Medicine, a degree rooted in allopathic medicine. This traditional approach focuses on diagnosing and treating diseases using medications, surgery, and other conventional methods. Osteopathic medical schools, on the other hand, award the DO degree, which stands for Doctor of Osteopathic Medicine. Osteopathic medicine emphasizes a holistic approach to health, incorporating osteopathic principles and practices that consider the whole person—body, mind, and spirit—in patient care.
A cornerstone of osteopathic medical education is training in osteopathic manipulative treatment (OMT), also called osteopathic manipulation or manual medicine. This hands-on technique focuses on the musculoskeletal system, aiming to improve function, reduce pain, and promote healing. DO students receive hundreds of hours of training in osteopathic manipulative medicine, a feature that distinguishes osteopathy from allopathic medical schools?
Holistic Approaches to Medicine
One of the primary reasons a student might choose to pursue a DO instead of an MD is the holistic approach emphasized in osteopathic medicine. Osteopathic doctors (DOs) are trained to view the patient as a whole rather than focusing solely on symptoms or diseases. This philosophy is particularly appealing to those who value preventative medicine and a comprehensive approach to patient care.
For example, while both DOs and MDs can practice medicine in all specialties, osteopathic principles often resonate strongly with individuals interested in primary care specialties such as family medicine, internal medicine, and pediatrics. DOs choose these fields at higher rates than their MD counterparts, reflecting the alignment of osteopathic training with the goals of care providers in these areas.
Easier Than MD? A Common Misconception
Some believe that getting into a DO program is easier than an MD program, primarily because the average GPA and MCAT scores for osteopathic medical students tend to be slightly lower than those of MD students. However, this does not mean the training or requirements for DOs are less rigorous. Both DO and MD programs demand a bachelor’s degree, completion of medical school, passing licensing exams, and successfully matching into a residency program. In fact, DOs must pass the Comprehensive Osteopathic Medical Licensing Examination (COMLEX), in addition to the option of taking the United States Medical Licensing Exam (USMLE), which is required for MD students.
Residency Programs and Specialty Training
DOs and MDs both must complete residency training to practice medicine. Historically, some residency programs favored MD seniors over DO students. However, recent changes in the U.S. medical education system, including the single accreditation system for graduate medical education, have created a more unified pathway for both types of doctors. Today, DOs can match into the same residency programs as MDs, making the difference between MD and DO less significant when it comes to postgraduate training.
Although both DOs and MDs can pursue any specialty, DOs are more likely to practice in primary care fields. This trend is encouraged by osteopathic medical schools, which often prioritize producing physicians for underserved areas and rural communities. That said, DOs also succeed in highly competitive specialties such as surgery, anesthesiology, and emergency medicine.
Osteopathic Manipulative Treatment in Practice
Another distinguishing feature of DOs is their use of osteopathic manipulative treatment. This skill is especially beneficial in managing musculoskeletal issues, such as chronic pain or sports injuries. While not all osteopathic doctors incorporate OMT into their daily practice, those who do find it enhances their ability to provide comprehensive care. Patients seeking a doctor trained in manual medicine or those who prefer a holistic approach to their care often turn to DOs for this reason.
Licensing and Medical Education
Both MDs and DOs must meet rigorous educational and licensing requirements to practice medicine. For MD students, the path involves attending allopathic medical schools, completing an MD program, passing the USMLE, and entering a residency program. Similarly, osteopathic medical students must attend an osteopathic medical school, complete a DO program, pass the COMLEX, and fulfill residency requirements. The American Osteopathic Association (AOA) and the Association of American Medical Colleges (AAMC) oversee the education and training of DOs and MDs, respectively.
A key aspect of osteopathic medical education is its emphasis on training in osteopathic manipulative treatment and osteopathic principles. These elements provide DO students with a unique perspective on health and patient care that complements the approaches taught in allopathic medical schools.
MD vs. DO: Which Path is Right for You?
The choice between an MD and a DO program often depends on personal interests, career goals, and philosophical alignment with approaches to medicine. Students drawn to the holistic approach, preventative medicine, and the integration of manual medicine techniques may find a DO program to be a better fit. Conversely, those focused on research-intensive specialties or who aim to practice in academic medicine might lean toward an MD degree.
Patient Perception and Career Opportunities
In the U.S., both MDs and DOs are fully licensed physicians who can prescribe medicine, perform surgeries, and practice in all areas of medicine. However, public awareness of the DO degree has historically been lower than that of the MD. Thanks to advocacy by organizations like the American Osteopathic Association and an increasing number of practicing osteopathic doctors, this perception is changing. Today, patients are more likely to appreciate the holistic approach and comprehensive care that DOs offer.
Career opportunities for DOs are virtually identical to those for MDs. Both types of doctors can work in hospitals, private practice, academia, or research. The growing number of DOs in the U.S., coupled with their increasing representation in competitive residency programs, highlights the parity between DO and MD degrees in modern medical practice.
Why Choose a DO Instead of an MD?
There are many reasons why a prospective medical student might opt for a DO program over an MD program:
- Holistic Philosophy: DOs are trained to see the patient as a whole, emphasizing preventative care and wellness.
- Osteopathic Manipulative Treatment: This hands-on approach provides an additional tool for patient care, especially in musculoskeletal medicine.
- Focus on Primary Care: Many osteopathic medical schools prioritize training doctors for primary care specialties, aligning with the needs of underserved populations.
- Personal Fit: Some students feel a stronger connection to the osteopathic philosophy and approach to patient care.
Conclusion
The difference between MD and DO programs lies not in the quality of medical education but in the philosophy and additional training offered. Both types of doctors play critical roles in the healthcare system, and the choice between becoming an MD or a DO depends on individual preferences and career goals. Whether through allopathic or osteopathic medicine, both pathways lead to the same ultimate goal: improving patient health and advancing the field of medicine.